Connect with us

Technology

Thinking outside the (Gear) box !

Published

on

Shares

Gearbox plays an important role in the system of load transmission, and is available in a variety of types, sizes and shapes. ICR feature takes a view on gearbox and its applications.

In the production process of cement manufacturing, there are many hardware which have a very important role to play. Moving equipment like rotary kiln, ball mill, roller press, vertical roller mill, conveyor belts are a few such examples. All of these use gearbox and gear drive. Since the equipment is continuously moving to carry out assigned jobs, the gearbox attached to the equipment requires proper and timely attention for maintenance. Out of these, the most important and critical gearbox is that of rotary kiln and next to that is of vertical roller mill. Among the maintenance fraternity of the cement industry, the subject of failure of a gearbox is largely debated. There have been several case studies inked and distributed across the industry which largely cover various kind of failures of gearbox says Jacob Thomas, Deputy General Manager with TECHPORT-Thane, the support organisation of LafargeHolcim, and a specialist in gearbox.

Incidentally Thomas has a very wide exposure of witnessing different kinds of failure across industry. He initially worked with Flender before joining ACC Ltd, the group company of erstwhile Holcim. He further says that the incidences of breakdown of gearbox have come down drastically in the last 3-4 years, since his peers are doing right job at plants.

Worldwide there are a very few manufacturers of gearbox and gear drive. For cement industry, Flender is a very common name, the other is Renk AG. Both these German companies have presence all across globe including China. One more multinational player that is active is FL Smidth MAAG Gear. Indian companies like Elecon (a very old and notable manufacturer), Vulcan Engineers from Western India, New Allenberry Works from East and Shathi Gears from Southern India also figure in the list. Indian manufacturers are much smaller as compared to that of their multinational counterparts, and their product range is also quite limited. Particularly, manufacturing a gearbox and gear drive for rotary kiln and for vertical roller mill is a super specialty area and requires understanding of user industry and the conditions in which the product is set to be used. An in-depth knowledge of metallurgy is a basic requirement. The product range of these multinational companies not only include gearbox for cement industry, but also includes automotive industry, shipping industry, power generation business, etc.

The first generation of gearbox for vertical roller mills was designed on the basis of a bevel-spur-gear arrangement. The challenge of this design was to balance the ratio of the two-gear stages equally. This allowed keeping the dimensions of the bevel wheel and the spur gear within a manageable range. In order to fulfill the demand of the cement industry, gear suppliers have since chosen a new gear arrangement. The spur gear design was replaced by a spiral bevel helical with multi planetary stage and consequently it was possible to reduce the overall dimension (compact design) and weight compared to the bevel-helical gears.

Nobody realises that a gearbox can have such a complicated design and performance, looking at it from the outside. It is a fine piece of sophisticated equipment produced based on the specifications provided by the client, under stringent conditions and strict quality control.

Sizable capital and efforts are put in by plant personnel in smooth running of rotary kiln and vertical roller mill. Engineers are even sent abroad for training, consultants are hired to have optimum performance of these equipment. Sprat Consultancy based at Kolkata is one such outfit which offers its services right from training to failure analysis to retro fitting of gearbox. The team members of Sprat had earlier worked at Flender and were part of the design and commissioning. They have a vast experience of troubleshooting the gearbox problems not only for the cement industry but also for the other sectors. The article written by Sengupta of Sprat Consultancy imposes the responsibility of smooth running on both – user and supplier. Thomas says that failure occurring at the stage of commissioning is to be treated differently as it relates to the design process of a gearbox. A different approach is to be taken to understand such failures. Failures during running and operation of the plant will altogether need different methodology. The failure of a gearbox cannot be attributed to only manufacturer. Before the order is finalised, the supplier asks for the details of the properties of the product to be processed in the mill and then suitably designs the machine. Any subsequent change in the input material can vary the process parameters and/or lead to improper functioning of the mill or the kiln. Today, due to pressure on becoming competitive, the design margins of the equipment are the least which must be borne in mind by the user. Therefore the saying-?something worked in the past should work now also?-is not acceptable.

By and large these failures press a panic button for the top management, as generally there is no ?spare gearbox? available for either kiln or VRM except in case of planned maintenance.

While investigating the failures-which starts right from the foundation of the machine in case of replacement of old gearbox with the new one and if old foundation is used-proper study must be done before final decision is taken. Another pointer as Thomas says is environment or surroundings of the gearbox. The dusty environment always leads to failure of bearings or motor.

The root-cause analysis is a perfect method to follow in case of failure of a gearbox. Many plants have their own format to carry out the root-cause analysis. Proper recording of the performance parameters is necessary. Debate and discussion on the failure is the first step to follow. Engineers have to update the history sheet of the machine including past failures, change of oil done, replacement of bearings or any other part, etc. The history sheet and the operating manual are two very important documents of the machine. For better results, the teamwork between the process personnel and maintenance engineers is another requirement. Their sharing of information will definitely lead to healthier work environment but can save plant from untimely failures.

Lubrication oil is too important and a challenging subject. Many a times, decisions on lube purchase are commercially driven and not on the basis of the properties of the bought-out items. Present generation of oils have many additives which enhance the performance of the oil and have less moisture absorption. Lower quality or cheaper oil need to be replaced more frequently and wastes precious productive hours which commercial-minded managers rarely appreciate. Experience suggests such decisions can be proved costly in the long run. The money spent on lubrication need not be based on price alone but on performance and price together. The decision on lubes has to be taken after consulting the OEM or the oil manufacturer. Proper documentation on replacement, partial replacement or testing must be maintained. It has been observed that analysis of used oil has been found a reliable source of understanding failures, Thomas says.

There are a good number of software packages available for predictive maintenance, which are purchased by the plant management that need to be used in the best possible way. This feature also covers a glimpse about a company called ?DALOG.? It is a company operating in a very niche area of condition monitoring of a gearbox and charging hefty fees. But industry still prefers to hire its services. Today there is no competitor for DALOG. It also offers service to the gearbox located at any plant from their office in Germany. It is a perfect marriage of instrumentation and information technology.

Involving and motivating technicians who are working with the plant for reasonable length of time have been found to be additional resource. If these people are vigilant and taken into confidence, they can immediately report the abnormalities of the gearbox like excessive vibration, noise or temperature which are the signals given by the machine before breakdown.

In short, gearbox and gear drives are very sophisticated piece of equipment manufactured at world-class manufacturing plants strictly as per the inputs given by the user and have to be used as per the instructions given and understood by the plant personnel. The available latest technology to access the health of the gearbox has to be at the disposal of the plant engineer, and then the incidence of failures will be minimal.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Concrete

Redefining Efficiency with Digitalisation

Published

on

By

Shares

Professor Procyon Mukherjee discusses how as the cement industry accelerates its shift towards digitalisation, data-driven technologies are becoming the mainstay of sustainability and control across the value chain.

The cement industry, long perceived as traditional and resistant to change, is undergoing a profound transformation driven by digital technologies. As global infrastructure demand grows alongside increasing pressure to decarbonise and improve productivity, cement manufacturers are adopting data-centric tools to enhance performance across the value chain. Nowhere is this shift more impactful than in grinding, which is the energy-intensive final stage of cement production, and in the materials that make grinding more efficient: grinding media and grinding aids.

The imperative for digitalisation
Cement production accounts for roughly 7 per cent to 8 per cent of global CO2 emissions, largely due to the energy intensity of clinker production and grinding processes. Digital solutions, such as AI-driven process controls and digital twins, are helping plants improve stability, cut fuel use and reduce emissions while maintaining consistent product quality. In one deployment alongside ABB’s process controls at a Heidelberg plant in Czechia, AI tools cut fuel use by 4 per cent and emissions by 2 per cent, while also improving operational stability.
Digitalisation in cement manufacturing encompasses a suite of technologies, broadly termed as Industrial Internet of Things (IIoT), AI and machine learning, predictive analytics, cloud-based platforms, advanced process control and digital twins, each playing a role in optimising various stages of production from quarrying to despatch.

Grinding: The crucible of efficiency and cost
Of all the stages in cement production, grinding is among the most energy-intensive, historically consuming large amounts of electricity and representing a significant portion of plant operating costs. As a result, optimising grinding operations has become central to digital transformation strategies.
Modern digital systems are transforming grinding mills from mechanical workhorses into intelligent, interconnected assets. Sensors throughout the mill measure parameters such as mill load, vibration, mill speed, particle size distribution, and power consumption. This real-time data, fed into machine learning and advanced process control (APC) systems, can dynamically adjust operating conditions to maintain optimal throughput and energy usage.
For example, advanced grinding systems now predict inefficient conditions, such as impending mill overload, by continuously analysing acoustic and vibration signatures. The system can then proactively adjust clinker feed rates and grinding media distribution to sustain optimal conditions, reducing energy consumption and improving consistency.

Digital twins: Seeing grinding in the virtual world
One of the most transformative digital tools applied in cement grinding is the digital twin, which a real-time virtual replica of physical equipment and processes. By integrating sensor data and
process models, digital twins enable engineers to simulate process variations and run ‘what-if’
scenarios without disrupting actual production. These simulations support decisions on variables such as grinding media charge, mill speed and classifier settings, allowing optimisation of energy use and product fineness.
Digital twins have been used to optimise kilns and grinding circuits in plants worldwide, reducing unplanned downtime and allowing predictive maintenance to extend the life of expensive grinding assets.

Grinding media and grinding aids in a digital era
While digital technologies improve control and prediction, materials science innovations in grinding media and grinding aids have become equally crucial for achieving performance gains.
Grinding media, which comprise the balls or cylinders inside mills, directly influence the efficiency of clinker comminution. Traditionally composed of high-chrome cast iron or forged steel, grinding media account for nearly a quarter of global grinding media consumption by application, with efficiency improvements translating directly to lower energy intensity.
Recent advancements include ceramic and hybrid media that combine hardness and toughness to reduce wear and energy losses. For example, manufacturers such as Sanxin New Materials in China and Tosoh Corporation in Japan have developed sub-nano and zirconia media with exceptional wear resistance. Other innovations include smart media embedded with sensors to monitor wear, temperature, and impact forces in real time, enabling predictive maintenance and optimal media replacement scheduling. These digitally-enabled media solutions can increase grinding efficiency by as much as 15 per cent.
Complementing grinding media are grinding aids, which are chemical additives that improve mill throughput and reduce energy consumption by altering the surface properties of particles, trapping air, and preventing re-agglomeration. Technology leaders like SIKA AG and GCP Applied Technologies have invested in tailored grinding aids compatible with AI-driven dosing platforms that automatically adjust additive concentrations based on real-time mill conditions. Trials in South America reported throughput improvements nearing 19 per cent when integrating such digital assistive dosing with process control systems.
The integration of grinding media data and digital dosing of grinding aids moves the mill closer to a self-optimising system, where AI not only predicts media wear or energy losses but prescribes optimal interventions through automated dosing and operational adjustments.

Global case studies in digital adoption
Several cement companies around the world exemplify digital transformation in practice.
Heidelberg Materials has deployed digital twin technologies across global plants, achieving up to 15 per cent increases in production efficiency and 20 per cent reductions in energy consumption by leveraging real-time analytics and predictive algorithms.
Holcim’s Siggenthal plant in Switzerland piloted AI controllers that autonomously adjusted kiln operations, boosting throughput while reducing specific energy consumption and emissions.
Cemex, through its AI and predictive maintenance initiatives, improved kiln availability and reduced maintenance costs by predicting failures before they occurred. Global efforts also include AI process optimisation initiatives to reduce energy consumption and environmental impact.

Challenges and the road ahead
Despite these advances, digitalisation in cement grinding faces challenges. Legacy equipment may lack sensor readiness, requiring retrofits and edge-cloud connectivity upgrades. Data governance and integration across plants and systems remains a barrier for many mid-tier producers. Yet, digital transformation statistics show momentum: more than half of cement companies have implemented IoT sensors for equipment monitoring, and digital twin adoption is growing rapidly as part of broader Industry 4.0 strategies.
Furthermore, as digital systems mature, they increasingly support sustainability goals: reduced energy use, optimised media consumption and lower greenhouse gas emissions. By embedding intelligence into grinding circuits and material inputs like grinding aids, cement manufacturers can strike a balance between efficiency and environmental stewardship.
Conclusion
Digitalisation is not merely an add-on to cement manufacturing. It is reshaping the competitive and sustainability landscape of an industry often perceived as inertia-bound. With grinding representing a nexus of energy intensity and cost, digital technologies from sensor networks and predictive analytics to digital twins offer new levers of control. When paired with innovations in grinding media and grinding aids, particularly those with embedded digital capabilities, plants can achieve unprecedented gains in efficiency, predictability and performance.
For global cement producers aiming to reduce costs and carbon footprints simultaneously, the future belongs to those who harness digital intelligence not just to monitor operations, but to optimise and evolve them continuously.

About the author:
Professor Procyon Mukherjee, ex-CPO Lafarge-Holcim India, ex-President Hindalco, ex-VP Supply Chain Novelis Europe,
has been an industry leader in logistics, procurement, operations and supply chain management. His career spans 38 years starting from Philips, Alcan Inc (Indian Aluminum Company), Hindalco, Novelis and Holcim. He authored the book, ‘The Search for Value in Supply Chains’. He serves now as Visiting Professor in SP Jain Global, SIOM and as the Adjunct Professor at SBUP. He advises leading Global Firms including Consulting firms on SCM and Industrial Leadership and is a subject matter expert in aluminum and cement. An Alumnus of IIM Calcutta and Jadavpur University, he has completed the LH Senior Leadership Programme at IVEY Academy at Western University, Canada.

Continue Reading

Concrete

Digital Pathways for Sustainable Manufacturing

Published

on

By

Shares

Dr Y Chandri Naidu, Chief Technology Officer, Nextcem Consulting highlights how digital technologies are enabling Indian cement plants to improve efficiency, reduce emissions, and transition toward sustainable, low-carbon manufacturing.

Cement manufacturing is inherently resource- and energy-intensive due to high-temperature clinkerisation and extensive material handling and grinding operations. In India, where cement demand continues to grow in line with infrastructure development, producers must balance capacity expansion with sustainability commitments. Energy costs constitute a major share of operating expenditure, while process-related carbon dioxide emissions from limestone calcination remain unavoidable.
Traditional optimisation approaches, which are largely dependent on operator experience, static control logic and offline laboratory analysis, have reached their practical limits. This is especially evident when higher levels of alternative fuel and raw materials (AFR) are introduced or when raw material variability increases.
Digital technologies provide a systematic pathway to manage this complexity by enabling
real-time monitoring, predictive optimisation and integrated decision-making across cement manufacturing operations.
Digital cement manufacturing is enabled through a layered architecture integrating operational technology (OT) and information technology (IT). At the base are plant instrumentation, analysers, and automation systems, which generate continuous process data. This data is contextualised and analysed using advanced analytics and AI platforms, enabling predictive and prescriptive insights for operators and management.

Digital optimisation of energy efficiency

  • Thermal energy optimisation
    The kiln and calciner system accounts for approximately 60 per cent to 65 per cent of total energy consumption in an integrated cement plant. Digital optimisation focuses on reducing specific thermal energy consumption (STEC) while maintaining clinker quality and operational stability.
    Advanced Process Control (APC) stabilises critical parameters such as burning zone temperature, oxygen concentration, kiln feed rate and calciner residence time. By minimising process variability, APC reduces the need for conservative over-firing. Artificial intelligence further enhances optimisation by learning nonlinear relationships between raw mix chemistry, AFR characteristics, flame dynamics and heat consumption.
    Digital twins of kiln systems allow engineers to simulate operational scenarios such as increased AFR substitution, altered burner momentum or changes in raw mix burnability without operational risk. Indian cement plants adopting these solutions typically report STEC reductions in the range of 2 per cent to 5 per cent.
  • Electrical energy optimisation
    Electrical energy consumption in cement plants is dominated by grinding systems, fans and material transport equipment. Machine learning–based optimisation continuously adjusts mill parameters such as separator speed, grinding pressure and feed rate to minimise specific power consumption while maintaining product fineness.
    Predictive maintenance analytics identify inefficiencies caused by wear, fouling or imbalance in fans and motors. Plants implementing plant-wide electrical energy optimisation typically achieve
    3 per cent to 7 per cent reduction in specific power consumption, contributing to both cost savings and indirect CO2 reduction.

Digital enablement of AFR
AFR challenges in the Indian context: Indian cement plants increasingly utilise biomass, refuse-derived fuel (RDF), plastic waste and industrial by-products. However, variability in calorific value, moisture, particle size, chlorine and sulphur content introduces combustion instability, build-up formation and emission risks.
Digital AFR management: Digital platforms integrate real-time AFR quality data from online analysers with historical kiln performance data. Machine learning models predict combustion behaviour, flame stability and emission trends for different AFR combinations. Based on these predictions, fuel feed distribution, primary and secondary air ratios, and burner momentum are dynamically adjusted to ensure stable kiln operation. Digitally enabled AFR management in cement plants will result in increased thermal substitution rates by 5-15 percentage points, reduced fossil fuel dependency, and improved kiln stability.

Digital resource and raw material optimisation
Raw mix control: Raw material variability directly affects kiln operation and clinker quality. AI-driven raw mix optimisation systems continuously adjust feed proportions to maintain target chemical parameters such as Lime Saturation Factor (LSF), Silica Modulus (SM), and Alumina Modulus (AM). This reduces corrective material usage and improves kiln thermal efficiency.
Clinker factor reduction: Reducing clinker factor through supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) such as fly ash, slag and calcined clay is a key decarbonisation lever. Digital models simulate blended cement performance, enabling optimisation of SCM proportions while maintaining strength and durability requirements.

Challenges and strategies for digital adoption
Key challenges in Indian cement plants include data quality limitations due to legacy instrumentation, resistance to algorithm-based decision-making, integration complexity across multiple OEM systems, and site-specific variability in raw materials and fuels.
Successful digital transformation requires strengthening the data foundation, prioritising high-impact use cases such as kiln APC and energy optimisation, adopting a human-in-the-loop approach, and deploying modular, scalable digital platforms with cybersecurity by design.

Future Outlook
Future digital cement plants will evolve toward autonomous optimisation, real-time carbon intensity tracking, and integration with emerging decarbonisation technologies such as carbon capture, utilisation and storage (CCUS). Digital platforms will also support ESG reporting and regulatory compliance.
Digital pathways offer a practical and scalable solution for sustainable cement manufacturing in India. By optimising energy consumption, enabling higher AFR substitution and improving resource efficiency, digital technologies deliver measurable environmental and economic benefits. With appropriate data infrastructure, organisational alignment and phased implementation, digital transformation will remain central to the Indian cement industry’s low-carbon transition.

About the author:
Dr Y Chandri Naidu is a cement industry professional with 30+ years of experience in process optimisation, quality control and quality assistance, energy conservation and sustainable manufacturing, across leading organisations including NCB, Ramco, Prism, Ultratech, HIL, NCL and Vedanta. He is known for guiding teams, developing innovative plant solutions and promoting environmentally responsible cement production. He is also passionate about mentoring professionals and advancing durable, resource efficient technologies for future of construction materials.

Continue Reading

Concrete

Turning Downtime into Actionable Intelligence

Published

on

By

Shares

Stoppage Insights instantly identifies root causes and maps their full operational impact.

In cement, mining and minerals processing operations, every unplanned stoppage equals lost production and reduced profitability. Yet identifying what caused a stoppage remains frustratingly complex. A single motor failure can trigger cascading interlocks and alarm floods, burying the root cause under layers of secondary events. Operators and maintenance teams waste valuable time tracing event chains when they should be solving problems. Until now.
Our latest innovation to our ECS Process Control Solution(1) eliminates this complexity. Stoppage Insights, available with the combined updates to our ECS/ControlCenter™ (ECS) software and ACESYS programming library, transforms stoppage events into clear, actionable intelligence. The system automatically identifies the root cause of every stoppage – whether triggered by alarms, interlocks, or operator actions – and maps all affected equipment. Operators can click any stopped motor’s faceplate to view what caused the shutdown instantly. The Stoppage UI provides a complete record of all stoppages with drill-down capabilities, replacing manual investigation with immediate answers.

Understanding root cause in Stoppage Insights
In Stoppage Insights, ‘root cause’ refers to the first alarm, interlock, or operator action detected by the control system. While this may not reveal the underlying mechanical, electrical or process failure that a maintenance team may later discover, it provides an actionable starting point for rapid troubleshooting and response. And this is where Stoppage Insights steps ahead of traditional first-out alarm systems (ISA 18.2). In this older type of system, the first alarm is identified in a group. This is useful, but limited, as it doesn’t show the complete cascade of events, distinguish between operator-initiated and alarm-triggered stoppages, or map downstream impacts. In contrast, Stoppage Insights provides complete transparency:

  • Comprehensive capture: Records both regular operator stops and alarm-triggered shutdowns.
  • Complete impact visibility: Maps all affected equipment automatically.
  • Contextual clarity: Eliminates manual tracing through alarm floods, saving critical response time.


David Campain, Global Product Manager for Process Control Systems, says, “Stoppage Insights takes fault analysis to the next level. Operators and maintenance engineers no longer need to trace complex event chains. They see the root cause clearly and can respond quickly.”

Driving results
1.Driving results for operations teams
Stoppage Insights maximises clarity to minimise downtime, enabling operators to:
• Rapidly identify root causes to shorten recovery time.
• View initiating events and all affected units in one intuitive interface.
• Access complete records of both planned and unplanned stoppages

  1. Driving results for maintenance and reliability teams
    Stoppage Insights helps prioritise work based on evidence, not guesswork:
    • Access structured stoppage data for reliability programmes.
    • Replace manual logging with automated, exportable records for CMMS, ERP or MES.(2)
    • Identify recurring issues and target preventive maintenance effectively.

  2. A future-proof and cybersecure foundation
    Our Stoppage Insights feature is built on the latest (version 9) update to our ACESYS advanced programming library. This industry-leading solution lies at the heart of the ECS process control system. Its structured approach enables fast engineering and consistent control logic across hardware platforms from Siemens, Schneider, Rockwell, and others.
    In addition to powering Stoppage Insights, ACESYS v9 positions the ECS system for open, interoperable architectures and future-proof automation. The same structured data used by Stoppage Insights supports AI-driven process control, providing the foundation for machine learning models and advanced analytics.
    The latest releases also respond to the growing risk of cyberattacks on industrial operational technology (OT) infrastructure, delivering robust cybersecurity. The latest ECS software update (version 9.2) is certified to IEC 62443-4-1 international cybersecurity standards, protecting your process operations and reducing system vulnerability.

What’s available now and what’s coming next?
The ECS/ControlCenter 9.2 and ACESYS 9 updates, featuring Stoppage Insights, are available now for:

  • Greenfield projects.
  • ECS system upgrades.
  • Brownfield replacement of competitor systems.
    Stoppage Insights will also soon integrate with our ECS/UptimeGo downtime analysis software. Stoppage records, including root cause identification and affected equipment, will flow seamlessly into UptimeGo for advanced analytics, trending and long-term reliability reporting. This integration creates a complete ecosystem for managing and improving plant uptime.

(1) The ECS Process Control Solution for cement, mining and minerals processing combines proven control strategies with modern automation architecture to optimise plant performance, reduce downtime and support operational excellence.
(2) CMMS refers to computerised maintenance management systems; ERP, to enterprise resource planning; and MES to manufacturing execution systems.

Continue Reading

Trending News