Environment
Energy conservation through energy efficient tech
Published
5 years agoon
By
adminThe article deals with the energy conservation achieved by adapting various energy-efficient technologies and incorporating energy-efficient operation.
Energy is one of the major inputs for the economic development of our country, more so with depleting fuel reserves. Energy consumption in industrial sector is accounting for about 50 per cent of the commercial energy available in our country. Among the industrial sector, nine sectors have been identified as highly energy-intensive. These include: power, fertilizer, iron and steel, cement, pulp and paper, aluminium, chlor-alkali, textile and railways.
In this scenario of energy shortage, increasing energy demands and price, particularly for developing countries like India, it may be difficult to pursue the present rate of development and will be forced to retard its development/industrialisation programmes for want of sufficient energy reserves, unless focused measures are taken. In this background, the imperative need for every citizen and the industry in particular is to contribute towards energy conservation and environmental sustainability.
This paper deals with the energy conservation achieved by adapting various energy-efficient technologies and incorporating energy-efficient operation. Various activities implemented to reduce power consumption are as enumerated below:
- Compressor power optimisation
- Pressure drop reduction in cyclone
- Single raw meal silo operation instead of two
- Star feeder instead of 3KS system
- SPRS for process mil fans
- Operated Turbo blowers instead of PD blowers
- Optimisation of air conditioner consumption
- Provided VFDs to potential equipment
- Installation of occupancy sensors in load centres
- Cogged belts in place of V belts & FRP blades in place of aluminium/CI blades
- Monitoring of special power on a daily basis and controlling of idle power consumption
Lets see the above energy conservative activities in more details:
Energy conservation activity – 1 – Compressor power optimisation
An air compressor is a device that converts power in to potential energy, stored in pressurised vessel. Compressor plays a major role in utility power consumption, Various energy efficient technologies adopted in our unit to optimise compressor power are as below:
Upgradation of old with energy efficient compressor
Background: In line 2 Pyro section, 1 No of 965CFM, Double stage, water cooled screw compressor, rated shaft power of 132kW (SF – 1.2) was in operation (24×7) for past 14 years, at an operating efficiency of 76 per cent and it consumes around 143 to 145 KW/hour as input power to deliver the specified volume at an pressure of 5.2 to 5.7 bar.
Action taken: Upgradation with latest energy efficient model (925CFM, air cooled, oil flooded double stage screw compressor of shaft power 110KW (SF – 1.1)
Benefits and savings:
- Power consumption reduced (17 KW/Hr)
- As this is an air cooled compressor, intangible benefit of reduction in cooling tower operation for 240 LPM (5 KW/Hr)
Installation of VFD in compressor
Background: For our packing plant operation, double stage air cooled, 535CFM screw compressor was in operation and it consumes around 0.32 to 0.35 units/tonne of cement packing. The loading and unloading pattern of compressor is not uniform. Since the inward movement of cement truck is at different timing and to maintain the truck TAT compressor need to operate on continuous basis, hence ideal running is more.
Action taken: Operating this compressor through VFD, which enabled speed variation of the motor according the pressure setting and constant pressure is maintained in line and ideal running avoided.
Benefits: Compressor power consumption reduced to 0.24 units/tonne of cement packing and for 0.1 units/tonne reduction in cement.
Total savings (units/tonne)Power cost (Rs/unit)Packing in line -2 FY (18-19)Annual savings, (Rs lakh/year) 0.14.8516192587.85
Installation of additional receiver tanks
Background: The compressor air generated in compressor room is directly fed to the receiver tank of CVRM-2 Building, fourth floor. Due to line layout and cement bag house operation, line header pressure is reduced by 0.8 bar and frequent loading/unloading is happening.
Action taken: One more buffer tank of 6,000 liter capacity is installed nearer to the compressor station at ground floor.
Benefits:
Pressure drop in common header line reduced around 0.5 bar
Generation pressure reduced from 6.2 to 5.7 bar
Savings:
Power savings – 0.1 units/tonne of cement grinding
Total savings (units/tonne)Power cost (Rs/unit) Cement grinding in CVRM-2 FY (18-19)Annual savings,
(Rs lakh)Investment cost (Rs lakh)ROI (months)v 0.14.8516152937.830.50.77
Optimisation of pressure settings and vigilant monitoring
Background: Compressors required for plant operation are connected in common header and tappings are taken from common header irrespective of pressure requirements. Also the pressure drop between the compressor end and load end is on higher side because of various piping sizes. Hence generation pressure setting is maintained more.
Action taken:
Higher volume requirement are taken from common header
High pressure and lower volume requirements at load end are compensated through booster
Operation of standby 950 CFM compressor during peak demand is compensated with smaller capacity compressors connected in the header and pressure settings are optimised
Also by vigilant monitoring and reviewing of compressor consumption on a daily
basis, leakages are arrested and minimised in the initial stage itself
Benefits:
Pressure drop reduced around 0.4 bar
Generation pressure reduced from 6 to 5.5 bar
Energy Conservation Activity – 2
Cyclones in modern cement plant: Modern cement production relies on conservation and efficient use of natural resources viz., raw materials and fuels. Kiln gases are used efficiently to preheat and dry raw materials before they enter the kiln. During design of cement plant pre heater, stages are added to the tower to reduce the pre heater exist temperature, as more heat is transferred to the fresh raw meal. Background: In our line-2 preheater system, it was observed that pressure drop across cyclone 1 was on higher side (i.e., around 250 mmwc instead of recommended range 90-120 mmwc), which affected the heat transfer in the system.
Action taken: For reducing pressure drop, it was decided to widen the gas inlet area. In first phase, the inlet area opening was increased to 250 mm and pressure drop got reduced to 220 mmwc. In second phase, it was further increased to 400 mm and the pressure drop got reduced to 180 mmwc
Benefits:
- Pressure drop across cyclone-1 reduced from 250 to 180 mmwc (i.e., 70 mmwc)
- PH fan power consumption reduced around 50 units/hour
- Improvement of flow in PH cyclones
- Collection efficiency improvement in PH cyclones
Savings: PH fan power consumption reduced around 150 units/hour
Total Savings (Units /Hr)Power Cost (Rs. / Unit)Running Hrs in FY (18-19)
Annual Savings, (Rs. Lakhs/year)Investment Cost (Rs. Lakhs)ROI (Months)
504.856560.215.912.31.73
Energy conservation activity – 3
Optimisation of raw meal silo operation – blending and extraction: In a cement plant, raw meal silo is meant for storing of raw-meal powder and for homogeneous process for better quality of cement. In Line 1 – 2 numbers of raw meal silo?s are there for this application.
Background: Our L1 kiln is producing clinker for all special cements like OWC, SLS , SRPC, etc. for OWC production, single silo is used, whereas for OPC clinker production two silos are simultaneously operated during feeding and extraction.
Due to this:
- Auxiliary power consumption was higher
- All the drives in the circuit were running and standby equipment are not available for operation during failure
- Hence, planned to optimise raw meal silo operation to save energy
Action taken: For OPC production, single silo operation logic was implemented without affecting product quality.
Benefits:
- Six drives were stopped in the circuit
- Ready standby circuit available to avoid breakdowns
- Reduction in spares and maintenance cost
Savings:
By stopping these equipment, power consumption reduction – 40 kW/hour
Total savings (Units/hour)Power cost (Rs/unit)Running hours in FY (18-19)Annual savings, (Rs Lakh/year)Investment cost (Rs lakh)
404.85592111.49Nil
Energy Conservation Activity – 4
Star feeder instead of 3KS system in cement mill feed: 3KS is an hydraulic system with three flaps, one flap gets open at a time and balance two flaps remains closed in-order to restrict false air entry inside the mill. Star feeder is a rotating feeder consisting of a horizontal shaft fitted with radial blades running within a close-fitting cylindrical chamber provided with an inlet and an outlet.
Background: CVRM-1 Mill – Materials fed through 3KS system and its drawbacks are:
- 40Frequent gate struck-up due to foreign materials entry
- Side liner worn out and leads to false air entry (around 23 per cent in CVRM-1 mill circuit)
- Periodic flap jamming due to moisture in materials
Action taken: For reducing the false air entry and other nuisance – 3KS upgraded with star feeder. In this activity, we eliminated one feeding belt (531BC3) from the circuit and its feeding belt 531-BC2 is extended to fed the mill through star feeder. Star feeder motor capacity and hydraulic pump motor capacities are same.
Benefits:
- Maintenance cost is reduced on account of one belt conveyor is eliminated
- False air is reduced to 13 per cent across the mill
- Elimination of 3KS hydraulic system maintenance
Savings:
Reduction in mill fan power consumption – 70 units/hour
Total savings (KW/hour)Power cost (Rs/ unit)Running hours in FY (18-19)
Annual savings, (Rs lakh)Investment cost (Rs lakh)ROI (Months)
704.855614.519.061710.70
Energy Conservation Activity – 5
SPRS for process mill fans: Slip energy recovery is one of the methods of controlling the speed of an slip ring induction motor. This method is also known as Static Scherbius Drive. In the rotor resistance control method, the slip power in the rotor circuit is wasted as I2R losses during the low-speed operation. The efficiency is also reduced. The slip power from the rotor circuit can be recovered and fed back to the AC source so as to utilise it outside the motor. Thus, the overall efficiency of the drive system can be increased. In a wound-field induction motor the slip rings allow easy recovery of the slip power, which can be electronically controlled to control the speed of the motor. The oldest and simplest technique to invoke this slip power recovery induction motor speed control is to mechanically vary the rotor resistance.
Background: The old SPRS system for CVRM-1 mill fan was installed in 1996 and it was served around 22 years. This SPRS system was outdated, spares are obsolete in the market and due to aging the reliability of this SPRS system is very poor. In last FY around eight months, it was not in operation because of non availability of spares. The speed range is 70 to 99 per cent.
Action taken: New SPRS system installed with wide speed range of 60 to 99 per cent. Also in the new system, the auto transformer is eliminated.
Savings:
- Operating speed range is wider (i.e. 60 to 99 per cent)
- Reliability of this new system is very high
- Spare available in market and maintenance cost is very cheap
- Auto transformer (575 to 1641 KVA) is eliminated in new system and the rating of recovery transformer also optimised to 450KVA from 837KVA. Hence transformer losses are reduced.
- Because of reliable system the recovery power/hour is around 150 units.
Total savings (units/hour)Power cost (Rs/ unit)Running hours in FY (18-19)Annual savings (Rs lakh/year)Investment cost (Rs lakh)ROI (Months)
1504.855614.540.854212.3
Energy Conservation Activity – 6
Operated turbo blowers instead of PD blowers: The PD blower is also known as positive displacement blower and it is used to move gas or air for a variety of applications. To be precise, these devices utilise positive displacement technology by trapping a certain volume of air then discharging or forcing it out against the system pressure. The air is usually forced in to some type of pipe or hose to propel materials or gas to a destination. PD blower efficiency will be around 45 to 65 per cent. Turbo blower is the latest technology – energy efficient blower and its efficiency will be around 82 per cent.
Background: PD blowers are used for PC and kiln coal pumping application and it consumes more power for pumping. It occupies more space and generates more heat and noise (requires big silencers) during operation. Also it needs more maintenance. Efficiency of PD blower is very low.
Action taken: Because of efficiency, turbo blowers are operated instead of PD blower for kiln and PC coal pumping application. It occupies less space, operation is very quiet. It has few moving parts hence low maintenance is required and no complex oil cooling system is required for turbo blowers.
Savings: Energy efficient blower and operating at an efficiency of > 82 per cent
Power saving – 95 units/hour (by operating turbo blower for kiln coal pumping – 40 units/hour and by operating turbo blower for PC coal pumping – 55 units/hour)
Energy Conservation Activity – 7
Optimisation of air conditioner power consumption: In line 2 around 222.5 TR of package ACs are installed and operated for maintaining the temperature in PLC, MVAC and VFD rooms, training centre and CCR as listed below:
Sr. NoLocationCapacity (TR)
1Load center 159.5
2Load center 251
3Bag House Load center34
4CVRM Load center22
5RTC22
6CCR34
Total222.5
In CCR & VFD -Load Center the AC’s are operated by 24×7 and in training centre based on need basis. Various energy-efficient technologies were adopted to optimise.
Air conditioner power as below:
Water cooled condenser in place of air cooled condenser Depending on the type of the cooling system the packaged air conditioners are divided as water cooled and air cooled condensers. In water cooled packaged air conditions, the condenser is cooled by the water. The condenser is of shell and tube type, with refrigerant flowing along the tube side and the cooling water flowing along the shell side. The water has to be supplied continuously in these systems to maintain functioning of the air conditioning system. In air cooled packaged air conditioners, the condenser of the refrigeration system is cooled by the atmospheric air. The packaged AC with the air cooled condensers are used more commonly than the ones with water cooled condensers since air is freely available
Background: In L 2, all the package ACs are deigned as air cooled and after five years of use full lifecycle, the cooling efficiency is not effective because of lesser heat transfer in condenser coils. (The thin aluminum fins in coils are choked completely, air is not passing through the fins and getting damaged during cleaning within five years of lifecycle). Hence to maintain the temperature additional AC?s were operated continuously in addition to the regular units.
Action taken: Replaced the air cooled condenser coils with water cooled condensers in phased manner and without operating separate water pumps for water supply, tappings taken from water tanks feed lines and return water line laid to cooling tower.
Benefits:
- Thus cooling efficiency of package AC’s improved
- Operation of additional units stopped and standby unit available in all locations to meet the demand during breakdowns
- Power saving achieved
- Maintenance reduced
Savings:
Power savings around – 90 units/hour
LocationPower consumption (units/hour) before installation of WC condenser
Power consumption (units/hour) after installation of WC condenser
Load center 15740
Load center 24832
Bag House Load center3216
CVRM Load center2613
RTC2613
CCR3216
Total221130
Optimisation of air condition space
By optimising the room space, air conditioner power consumption reduced and room temperature maintained effectively.
Background: In bag house, the room size is larger and drive panels are accommodated within 3/4th of the room. Similarly in CVRM 2 Load center, the the false ceiling height is on higher elevated level and cooling duct is passing above 2 meters height over the panels. Hence cooling of more areas in done unnecessarily in both load the centers leads to power wastage and requires additional unit operation for effective cooling.
Action taken: In bag house, the cooling area partition modified along with the cooling duct modification to the required space and all other opening outside the new partition were closed. Similarly in CVRM-2 load centre, false ceiling and duct height reduced in such a way that the duct passes at 0.5 meter height over the panels. Thus effective cooling of load centres and panels ensured and additional unit operation is completely stopped.
Benefits:
Standby unit available in both locations to meet the demand during breakdowns
Power saving achieved
AC plant operation based on room temperature instead of return air Background: Package AC’s operation and cutoff is based on return air temperature. Due to leakage/improper flow of return air to the machine room, the AC unit is operated continuously and the room temperature is below the set point. This leads to unnecessary more cooling of load centres, CCR and wastage of power.
Action taken: Temperature controllers installed in all load centres, CCR and interlocked the control circuit of package AC’s with temperature controllers. Nowadays based on room temperature package AC’s are getting one or off. Thus power saving achieved.
Benefits: Power saving achieved. Other projects In addition to the above, various other Encon measures implemented as required, including VFDs for all process cooler fans and key auxilliary bag filter fans, occupancy sensors for the load centres and office building, cogged V belts in-place of V belt for blower and AHU’s. Further, for sustenance and continual improvements, daily energy monitoring of the specific power consumption is done through a structured format, capturing the drive wise power along with key operational parameters and accordingly brainstorming done, corrective actions taken and power optimised.
ABOUT THE AUTHOR: The article is authored by R. Rajamohan, Sr. General Manager( IE, Environment, PH) from Dalmia Cement Bharat Ltd., Dalmiapurum, Trichy.
ICR discusses India’s rapid advances in renewable energy, on track to exceed its 2030 targets, even as the rising energy demands challenge complete reliance on sustainable sources.
The cement industry, a cornerstone of infrastructure development, has long been associated with high emissions, particularly of CO2. This sector alone is responsible for approximately 8 per cent of global carbon dioxide emissions, primarily due to the energy-intensive processes of clinker production and calcination. Beyond carbon emissions, cement production also generates particulates, nitrogen oxides (NOx), sulphur oxides (SOx), and other pollutants, contributing to environmental degradation and health risks. With the global push towards sustainable practices and carbon neutrality, addressing emissions in the cement industry has become imperative.
According to Climate Change Performance Index, India ranks 7 in 2024. India receives a high ranking in the GHG Emissions and Energy Use categories, but a medium in Climate Policy and Renewable Energy, as in the previous year. While India is the world’s most populous country, it has relatively low per capita emissions. Data shows that in the per capita GHG category, the country is on track to meet a benchmark of well below 2°C.
India’s situation underscores the complexity of transitioning to sustainable energy systems in the face of rising and fluctuating energy needs. International support is crucial for India to access advanced technologies, financial resources, and best practices that can accelerate its transition to a sustainable energy future. Our analysis shows that with current policies, India will overachieve its conditional NDC targets of achieving 50 per cent non-fossil capacity by 2030, so it could set stronger targets. India has ambitious renewable energy plans as outlined in the National Electricity Plan 2023 (NEP2023) aiming for a share of installed capacity of 57 per cent and 66 per cent in 2026-27 and 2031-32, respectively. Share of renewable energy capacity in India reached 44 per cent, ranked fourth in the world in renewable energy capacity installations in 2023, after China, the US and Germany. The NEP2023 is reflected in the lower bound of our current policy and action pathway.
India has seen a steady increase in renewable energy deployment, including both utility-scale and rooftop solar, leading to the share of coal capacity dropping below 50 per cent for the first time. However, this increase in renewable energy capacity is barely able to keep up with the surging demand. As a result, the electricity generation share of renewable energy, including large hydro, remains at around 18 per cent, showing no improvement since last year. Investment in renewable energy projects in India are projected to increase by over 83 per cent to around USD 16.5 bn in 2024, with fossil fuel companies also diversifying their investments into the renewable sector. Despite this, India has not committed to phasing out coal power or fossil gas.
The National Electricity Plan indicated a temporary halt in coal capacity addition, but current under-construction capacity exceeds the threshold stated in these plans. While new gas power projects have been abandoned, the utilisation of existing gas power plants has increased to meet energy demand driven by severe heat stress.
Understanding Emissions in Cement Production
Primary Sources of Emissions: Cement production emissions stem mainly from three sources: calcination, fuel combustion, and electricity use. During calcination, limestone is heated to produce clinker, releasing CO2 as a by-product. This process alone accounts for roughly 60 per cent of emissions in cement manufacturing. The remaining emissions result from burning fossil fuels in kilns to achieve the high temperatures needed for calcination and from electricity consumption across production stages.
Raju Ramchandran, SVP Manufacturing (Cluster Head – Central), Nuvoco Vistas, says, “We consistently track air emissions from fuel combustion in our cement manufacturing and power generation operations. The burning of fossil fuels releases pollutants such as Oxides of Sulphur (SOx), Oxides of Nitrogen (NOx), and Particulate Matter (PM), which require stringent monitoring.”
“We ensure compliance with regulatory standards by using the Continuous Emission Monitoring System (CEMS) to monitor these emissions. For the FY 23-24, both our stack and fugitive emissions have stayed within the permissible limits set by Pollution Control Boards. Moreover, our ongoing monitoring of fugitive emissions ensures that we meet the prerequisite air quality standards,” he adds.
In addition to CO2, the cement industry releases various pollutants that pose risks to air quality and public health. These include particulate matter, NOx, and SOx, which can lead to respiratory and cardiovascular issues, acid rain, and ecosystem imbalances.
Governments worldwide are setting increasingly stringent regulations to curb industrial emissions. Standards such as the EU Emissions Trading System and India’s National Action Plan on Climate Change encourage cement manufacturers to adopt cleaner technologies. Many countries now impose limits on NOx, SOx and particulate emissions, with the aim of minimising the industry’s environmental impact.
Challenges in Reducing Emissions
High carbon intensity of cement production: Cement’s high carbon intensity largely stems from the chemical reactions involved in transforming limestone into clinker, making emissions difficult to reduce without altering core processes. Additionally, achieving the necessary kiln temperatures requires significant energy, often derived from coal or natural gas.
Operational limitations: Altering the traditional cement production process can compromise the quality and durability of the end product. Adapting existing production lines for lower emissions involves extensive R&D and technical trials to ensure the finished cement meets industry standards.
Financial constraints: The cost of implementing green technology is high, creating economic challenges, particularly for smaller cement manufacturers. Equipment upgrades, energy-efficient kilns, and carbon capture facilities require considerable investment, which many companies find difficult to justify without strong financial incentives.
Balancing market demands and environmental goals: With global infrastructure demands rising, the cement industry faces pressure to meet growing production needs while simultaneously working to reduce emissions. Balancing these competing demands requires innovation, efficient resource management, and support from stakeholders.
Technological Innovations for Emission Reduction
Alternative fuels and energy sources: One of the most effective ways to reduce emissions is by replacing fossil fuels with alternatives like waste-derived fuels, biomass, or biofuels. Some manufacturers are incorporating solar and wind energy to power auxiliary processes, further reducing reliance on traditional energy sources.
Sudhir Pathak, Head- Central Design & Engg (CDE), QA, Green Hydrogen, Hero Future Energies, says, “The cement industry is one of the largest consumers of grid power (Scope 2) and also a guzzler of in-process fossil CO2 (Scopem1) including process-based CO2 through limekilns. Decarbonisation can be achieved only up to 50 per cent to 60 per cent through plain hybrid solar and wind. However, for achieving balance 40 per cent, storage is essential, be it chemical or mechanical. Today, HFE is ready to provide such bespoke storage solutions as is evident through several complex RTC tenders that we have won in the last 6-8 months floated by agencies like SECI, NTPC and SJVN. These include tenders for FDRE projects, peak power, load following, etc. Further, regarding green hydrogen and its derivatives, we are ready to apply these for decarbonising industrial heating and mobility.”
Carbon Capture and Storage (CCS): CCS technology captures emissions at the source, storing CO2 to prevent it from entering the atmosphere. Recent advancements in CCS technology make it a viable option for large-scale cement plants, although high costs and infrastructure requirements remain obstacles to widespread adoption.
Clinker Substitution: Reducing clinker content is a promising method for emission reduction, achieved by using supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) such as fly ash, slag, and calcined clay. These materials not only reduce CO2 emissions but also enhance the durability and performance of cement. SCMs are gradually becoming industry-standard components, especially in eco-friendly and green cement products.
Rajesh Kumar Nayma, Assistant General Manager – Environment, Wonder Cement, says, “The use of AFR plays a critical role in our strategy to reduce the environmental footprint of cement production. By substituting traditional fossil fuels with waste-derived alternatives like biomass, refuse-derived fuel (RDF) and industrial by-products, we significantly lower CO2 emissions and reduce the demand for natural resources. The utilisation of supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs), such as fly ash, helps in reducing clinker consumption, which is a major source of carbon emissions in cement production. This not only decreases our reliance on energy-intensive processes but also promotes waste recycling and resource efficiency. AFR adoption is an integral part of our commitment to the circular economy, ensuring that we minimise waste and optimise the use of materials throughout the production cycle, ultimately contributing to a more sustainable and eco-friendly cement industry.”
“WCL is exploring transitioning from fossil fuels to cleaner alternatives like biofuels or hydrogen or RDF/plastic waste/other hazardous waste. Till date, 5 per cent TSR has been achieved, while the intent is to achieve more than 20 per cent TSR. WCL is utilising the hazardous and other waste as an alternative fuel or raw material. We have used more than 3 lakh metric tonne of hydrogen waste and other waste in FY-2023-24,” he adds.
Improving energy efficiency is critical for emissions reduction. Technologies like high-efficiency kilns, heat recovery systems, and process optimisation techniques are helping manufacturers achieve more output with less energy. These measures reduce the carbon footprint while lowering operational costs.
The Role of SCMs
SCMs serve as partial replacements for clinker, providing a dual benefit of reduced carbon emissions and improved product resilience. The use of materials like fly ash and slag also helps mitigate industrial waste, contributing to a circular economy. Fly ash, slag, and silica fume are among the most widely used SCMs. Each has unique properties that contribute to cement’s strength, workability, and durability. By incorporating SCMs, manufacturers can produce cement with a lower environmental footprint without compromising quality.
While SCMs are effective, several obstacles hinder their widespread adoption. Supply chain constraints, material variability, and lack of technical standards are challenges that manufacturers face. Additionally, geographic limitations impact access to certain SCMs, creating disparities in their usage across regions.
Policy and Industry Collaboration
Policies play a critical role in driving green transitions within the cement industry. Carbon credits, tax incentives, and funding for R&D are some measures governments have introduced to support emission reduction. India’s Perform, Achieve, and Trade (PAT) scheme is an example of a policy incentivising industrial energy efficiency.
Collaborations between government entities, private corporations, and research institutions foster innovation and accelerate the adoption of sustainable practices. Partnerships can also help address funding gaps, allowing companies to explore new technologies without bearing the full financial burden.
International frameworks such as the Paris Agreement and industry-led efforts like the Global Cement and Concrete Association (GCCA) are setting targets for sustainable cement production. These initiatives encourage the sector to adopt environmentally friendly practices and set a roadmap toward achieving net-zero emissions.
Towards a Net-Zero Future
Reaching net-zero emissions is an ambitious but necessary goal for the cement industry. Realistic targets, set with interim milestones, allow companies to gradually transition to greener processes while maintaining production efficiency. Continued investment in R&D is crucial for discovering new methods of emission reduction. Emerging technologies such as carbon-negative materials, alternative binders, and low-carbon clinkers hold promise for the future, potentially transforming cement production into a more sustainable process.
Increasingly, consumers and investors are prioritising sustainability, placing pressure on companies to reduce their environmental impact. This shift in consumer sentiment is driving the cement industry to adopt green practices and focus on transparency in emissions reporting.
Conclusion
The journey toward reducing environmental impact in the cement industry is complex and multifaceted, requiring a combination of innovation, policy support, and industry collaboration. By adopting alternative fuels, implementing carbon capture technology, integrating SCMs, and improving energy efficiency, the industry can take significant strides in minimising its carbon footprint. Achieving sustainability in cement production is essential not only for the industry’s future but also for the planet’s well-being. Together, industry players, policymakers, and consumers can support the transition to a net-zero future, ensuring that cement remains a vital yet sustainable component of global infrastructure.
– Kanika Mathur
Concrete
Red River Formation in Kiln Operations
Published
2 months agoon
November 22, 2024By
adminDr SB Hegde, Professor, Jain College of Engineering and Technology, Hubli, and Visiting Professor, Pennsylvania State University, USA, helps us understand the red river formation in cement kiln operations, its causes, impacts and mitigation strategies.
Red river formation in cement kilns, where molten clinker flows uncontrollably in the cooler, is a costly problem for cement plants. The phenomenon not only affects clinker quality but also leads to significant operational disruptions, increased energy consumption and accelerated wear on kiln refractory bricks. Understanding the factors that cause red river formation and implementing strategies to prevent it are critical to maintaining operational efficiency and clinker quality.
This paper explores the causes of red river formation, the operational impacts it has on kiln performance, and the various mitigation strategies that cement plants can adopt. Additionally, safety considerations associated with the prevention and handling of red river formation are discussed, with practical insights from case studies of successful plant interventions in India and globally.
Causes of red river formation
Red river formation is primarily caused by improper kiln operations, including fluctuating kiln temperatures, oxygen levels, and cooler inefficiency. The following parameters are essential contributors:
Kiln temperature: Inconsistent temperature control in the kiln’s burning zone, often exceeding 1500°C, creates an imbalance between the solid and molten clinker phases, leading to red river formation. Maintaining temperatures within a more stable range of 1470-1490°C ensures that the clinker remains solid as it moves into the cooler.
Oxygen levels and CO concentrations: Oxygen levels above 2.5 per cent increase the risk of over-combustion, while elevated CO levels above 0.3 per cent indicate incomplete combustion, both contributing to excessive clinker melting. Optimising oxygen levels to 1.8-2.0 per cent minimises the risk.
Raw mix composition: The raw mix plays a vital role in clinker formation. A high liquid phase due to improper ratios of silica, alumina, and iron oxide can lead to excessive melting. Controlling the silica modulus (SM: 2.3-2.7) and alumina modulus (AM: 1.3-1.8) ensures a more stable clinker and reduces the risk of red river formation. If the raw mix is improperly proportioned, red river formation becomes more likely due to high fluxing compounds that melt at lower temperatures.
Kiln speed and torque: Kiln speeds that fluctuate below 3.4 rpm can cause material buildup, while kiln torque exceeding 50-60 per cent indicates stress that can lead to clinker instability.
Cooler efficiency: Inefficiencies in the clinker cooler, with efficiency levels below 78 per cent, can exacerbate red river formation. Clinker that is not cooled properly will remain molten for longer, allowing it to flow uncontrollably. Coolers should maintain exit temperatures between 180-200°C to prevent red river incidents.
Impact on clinker quality and kiln performance
The occurrence of red river has numerous negative impacts on both clinker quality and kiln performance:
Clinker quality: Red river formation results in poor clinker grindability, higher variability in free lime content and inconsistent cement properties. Poor clinker reactivity reduces both early and late strength development in the final cement product.
Increased heat consumption: Red river typically increases specific heat consumption by 3-5 per cent, resulting in higher fuel usage. These inefficiencies can significantly affect the plant’s cost structure, driving up operational expenses.
Refractory damage: The molten clinker accelerates the wear of refractory bricks in the kiln, especially in the burning zone and cooler transition areas. Brick life can decrease by 25-30 per cent, leading to more frequent replacements and higher maintenance costs.
Equipment and instrumentation damage: The uncontrolled molten flow of clinker during red river incidents can damage cooler plates, kiln discharge systems, and even temperature sensors and thermocouples, leading to costly repairs and prolonged downtime.
Mitigation strategies
Mitigating red river formation requires a multi-faceted approach combining operational optimisation, automation and staff training:
Kiln temperature control: Maintaining stable burning zone temperatures in the 1470-1490°C range is key to preventing excessive melting of clinker. Advanced temperature monitoring systems can help regulate temperature fluctuations.
Cooler efficiency optimisation: To ensure proper cooling, cooler efficiency must be maintained at 78-80 per cent, with clinker exit temperatures not exceeding 200°C. Real-time airflow adjustments in grate coolers improve cooling performance, solidifying the clinker at the appropriate stage.
Automation and data analytics: Advanced Process Control (APC) systems using data analytics can monitor critical kiln parameters—such as temperature, oxygen levels, and torque—in real-time, allowing for predictive maintenance and early intervention when red river signs appear. This technology has been implemented successfully in leading plants globally to prevent red river formation.
Indian case studies
Case Study 1: Cement Plant in South India – Optimisation of Kiln Parameters
A cement plant in South India faced recurrent red river issues due to high kiln temperatures and low cooler efficiency. After comprehensive process audits, the plant optimised its kiln temperature to 1480°C, reduced oxygen levels to 1.9 per cent, and upgraded its cooler to an efficiency of 80 per cent. These changes reduced red river incidents by 85 per cent, saving the plant Rs 10 million in energy costs annually and improving clinker quality by
15 per cent.
Case Study 2: Cement Plant in North India – Cooler Upgrade and Automation
A northern India plant increased cooler efficiency from 70 per cent to 78 per cent by installing an advanced grate cooler. This reduced clinker exit temperatures to 190°C, preventing red river formation. Automation systems provided real-time adjustments, decreasing the frequency of incidents by 75 per cent and saving `12 million annually.
Global Case Studies
Case Study 1: European Plant – Automation Success
A German cement plant, experiencing red river issues due to fluctuating oxygen levels, installed an advanced data-driven automation system. The system stabilised oxygen at 1.9 per cent and maintained kiln temperature at 1,475-1,485°C, reducing red river by 90 per cent. Clinker quality improved by 10 per cent, with a reduction in specific heat consumption by 4 per cent.
Case study 2: US Plant – Operator Training and Process Optimisation
A US cement plant reduced red river occurrences by 70 per cent through kiln speed optimisation (3.8 rpm) and comprehensive operator training. Improved monitoring of kiln torque and cooler exit temperatures led to higher cooler efficiency (75 per cent) and an annual savings of $2 million.
Safety Aspects
Safety is a paramount concern in red river incidents. When molten clinker flows uncontrollably, it poses a significant risk to personnel working near the kiln and cooler areas.
To mitigate these risks:
- Clearance zones: Kiln and cooler areas should have strict clearance zones for personnel when red river incidents are detected.
- Protective gear and training: Personnel should be equipped with proper protective equipment (PPEs) and trained to handle emergencies involving molten clinker. Emergency shutdown procedures should be well-documented and rehearsed.
- Automation and early warning systems: Automation can provide early warning systems that alert operators to potential red river formation before it becomes critical, ensuring safe intervention.
Conclusion
Red river formation remains a major operational challenge for cement plants, but it can be effectively mitigated through proper kiln temperature control, cooler efficiency optimisation and the use of advanced automation systems.
The case studies highlight the importance of process improvements and staff training in reducing red river occurrences, improving clinker quality, and lowering operational costs. Additionally, safety
measures must be prioritised to protect personnel from the risks posed by molten clinker. By incorporating these strategies, cement plants can ensure consistent kiln performance and enhanced operational efficiency.
References
1. Duda, W. H. (1985). Cement Data Book. International Process Engineering in the Cement Industry. Bauverlag GmbH.
2. Javed, I., & Sobolev, K. (2020). “Use of Automation in Modern Cement Plants.” Cement and Concrete Research, 130, 105967.
3. Tamilselvan, P., & Kumar, R. (2023). “Optimisation of Kiln and Cooler Systems in Indian Cement Plants.” Indian Cement Review, 34(7), 42-48.
4. Martin, L. (2019). “Case Studies of Red River Mitigation in European Cement Plants.” International Journal of Cement Production, 12(2), 63-78.
5. Schorr, H. (2021). “Advanced Process Control in Cement Manufacturing.” Cement International, 19(3), 30-37.
6. Singh, V. K., & Gupta, A. (2022). “Impact of Raw Mix on Clinker Formation and Kiln Operations.” Global Cement Magazine, 14(4), 22-29.
About the author: Dr SB Hegde brings over thirty years of leadership experience in the cement industry in India and internationally. He has published over 198 research papers and holds six patents, with four more filed in the USA in 2023. His advisory roles extend to multinational cement companies globally and a governmental Think Tank, contributing to research and policy. Recognised for his contributions, he received the ‘Global Visionary Award’ in 2020 from the Gujarat Chambers of Commerce and Industry.
As the cement industry prioritises sustainability and performance, Supplementary Cementitious Materials (SCMs) are redefining standards, explains Tushar Khandhadia, General Manager – Production, Udaipur Cement Works.
What role do supplementary cementitious materials (SCMs) play in enhancing the performance and sustainability of cement and concrete?
SCMs play a crucial role in enhancing the performance and sustainability of cement and concrete. These materials are added to concrete to improve its properties such as strength, durability, and workability, as well as to reduce the environmental impact of cement production. The addition of SCMs to cement reduces the amount of Portland cement required to manufacture concrete, reducing the carbon footprint of the concrete. These materials are often industrial waste products or by-products that can be used as a replacement for cement, such as fly ash, slag and silica fume.
SCMs also reduce the amount of water required to produce concrete, which reduces the environmental impact of concrete production. This is achieved through their ability to improve the workability of concrete, allowing the same amount of work to be done with less water.
In addition, SCMs improve the durability of concrete by reducing the risk of cracking and improving resistance to chemical attack and other forms of degradation.
How has your company integrated SCMs into its production process, and what challenges have you encountered?
The integration of SCMs into cement and concrete production may pose certain challenges in the areas of sourcing, handling and production optimisation.
- Sourcing: Finding an adequate and reliable supply of SCMs can be a challenge. Some SCMs, such as fly ash and slag, are readily available by-products of other industrial processes, while others such as silica fume or metakaolin may be more difficult to source.
- Handling: The storage, handling, and transportation of SCMs require special considerations due to their physical and chemical properties. For instance, some SCMs are stored in moist conditions to prevent them from drying out and becoming airborne, which could pose a safety risk to workers.
- Production optimisation: The addition of SCMs into the mix may require adjustments to the production process to achieve the desired properties of cement and concrete. For example, the use of SCMs may affect the setting time, workability, strength gain, and other properties of the final product, which may require reconfiguration of the production process.
- Quality control: The addition of SCMs may introduce variability in the properties of cement and concrete, and rigorous quality control measures are necessary to ensure the final product meets the required specifications and standards.
Proper planning, handling and production optimisation are essential in overcoming the challenges encountered during the integration process.
Can you share insights on how SCMs such as fly ash, slag and silica fume impact the durability and strength of concrete in different environmental conditions?
- Fly ash is a by-product of coal combustion and is widely used as an SCM in the production of concrete. When added to concrete, fly ash reacts with the calcium hydroxide present in the concrete to form additional cementitious materials, resulting in improved strength and durability. Fly ash increases the durability of concrete by improving its resistance to sulphate and acid attacks, reducing shrinkage and decreasing the permeability of concrete. Fly ash also enhances the workability and pumpability of concrete while reducing the heat of hydration, which reduces the risk of thermal cracking. In cold climates, fly ash helps to reduce the risk of freeze-thaw damage.
- Slag is a by-product of steel production and is used as an SCM because of its high silica and alumina content. When added to concrete, slag reacts with the calcium hydroxide present in the concrete to form additional cementitious materials, resulting in improved strength and durability. Slag increases the durability of concrete by improving its resistance to sulphate and acid attacks, reducing shrinkage and improving the strength of concrete over time. Slag also enhances the workability of concrete, reduces the heat of hydration, and improves the resistance of concrete to chloride penetration.
- Silica fume is a by-product of the production of silicon and ferrosilicon alloys and is used as an SCM because of its high silica content. When added to concrete, silica fumes react with the calcium hydroxide present in the concrete to form additional cementitious materials, resulting in improved strength and durability. Silica fume increases the durability of concrete by improving its resistance to sulphate and acid attacks, reducing permeability, and improving abrasion resistance. Silica fume also enhances the workability of concrete, reduces the heat of hydration, and improves the resistance of concrete to chloride penetration.
Overall, the use of SCMs such as fly ash, slag and silica fume can significantly improve the durability and strength of concrete in different environmental conditions. Their impact on concrete varies depending on the availability, physical and chemical properties of the specific SCM being used and proper testing and engineering analysis should be done for each mix design in order to optimise the final product.
With the global push for sustainability, how do SCMs contribute to reducing the carbon footprint of cement production?
SCMs provide an environmentally friendly alternative to traditional Portland cement by reducing the amount of clinker required to produce cement. Clinker is the main ingredient in Portland cement and is produced by heating limestone and other raw materials to high temperatures, which releases significant GHG emissions. Thus, by using SCMs, less clinker is required, thereby reducing GHG emissions, energy use and the environmental impact of cement production. Some SCMs such as fly ash and slag are by-products of other industrial processes, meaning that their use in cement production reduces waste and enhances resource efficiency. Moreover, the use of SCMs can enhance the properties of concrete, thereby increasing its durability and service life which helps to further reduce the overall embodied carbon of the structure.
In short, the use of SCMs contributes to reducing the carbon footprint of cement production by improving the efficiency of resource utilisation and reducing greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions during the production process. This has led to an increased demand for SCMs in the construction industry, as environmental concerns and sustainable development goals have become more prominent factors in the selection of building materials.
What strategies or innovations has your company adopted to ensure a consistent and reliable supply of SCMs, given their reliance on industrial by-products?
- Developing partnerships with suppliers: Many cement and concrete manufacturers establish long-term partnerships with suppliers of SCMs. These partnerships provide a reliable supply of high-quality SCMs, improve supply chain efficiency, and often provide access to new sources of SCMs.
- Advanced SCM processing techniques: Many companies are investing in advanced processing techniques to unlock new sources of high-quality SCMs. Advanced processing techniques include new separation processes, calcination techniques, and chemical activation methods.
- Alternative SCM sources: Many companies are exploring alternative SCM sources to supplement or replace traditional SCMs. Examples include agricultural by-products such as rice hull ash or sugar cane bagasse ash, which can be used in place of fly ash.
- Quality control measures: Strict quality control measures are necessary to ensure consistent quality of SCMs. Many companies use advanced testing methods, such as particle size analysis, chemical analysis, and performance testing, to validate the quality of SCM materials used in production.
- Supply chain diversification: Diversifying suppliers and SCM sources is another way to ensure a reliable supply. This reduces the risk of supply chain disruptions caused by factors such as natural disasters, market changes, or geopolitical risks.
The strategies and innovations adopted to ensure a consistent and reliable supply of SCMs include establishing long-term partnerships with suppliers, investing in advanced processing techniques, exploring alternative SCM sources, implementing strict quality control measures, and diversifying supply chains. By implementing these approaches, we ensure that use of SCMs in cement production is an effective and viable solution for reducing the environmental impact of operations
How does the use of SCMs align with your company’s broader goals around circular economy and resource efficiency?
Here are some ways in which the use of SCMs supports these goals:
- Reducing waste: The use of SCMs, such as fly ash and slag, diverts significant quantities of industrial waste from landfills, turning it into a valuable resource that can be used in construction. This helps to reduce waste and conserve natural resources.
- Reducing carbon emissions: Cement production is a significant contributor to greenhouse gas emissions, and the use of SCMs can significantly reduce the amount of cement required in concrete mixtures. This helps to reduce the carbon footprint of construction activities and move towards a low-carbon economy.
- Enhancing resource efficiency: The use of SCMs can reduce the demand for raw materials, energy, and water in the production of concrete. This not only conserves natural resources but also reduces the costs associated with the extraction, transportation and processing of these materials.
- Closing the loop: SCMs encourage closed-loop systems in the construction sector, where waste materials from one process become input materials for another. This can improve the efficiency and sustainability of the construction industry.
- Supporting sustainable design practices: The use of SCMs can support sustainable design practices by improving the durability and performance of structures while also reducing their environmental impact. This supports a circular approach to design, construction and operation of buildings and infrastructure
that improves their social, economic and environmental sustainability.
What future trends or developments do you foresee in the use of SCMs within the cement industry?
Future trends in the use of SCMs within the cement industry are likely to focus on: increased utilisation of diverse waste-derived SCMs, development of new SCM sources to address potential shortages, advanced characterisation techniques to optimise SCM blends and data-driven approaches to predict and optimise SCM usage for reduced carbon footprint and improved concrete performance; all driven by the growing need for sustainable cement production and stricter environmental regulations.
Key aspects of this trend include:
- Expanding SCM sources: Exploring a wider range of industrial byproducts and waste materials like recycled concrete aggregate, activated clays and certain types of industrial minerals as potential SCMs to reduce reliance on traditional sources like fly ash, which may become increasingly limited.
- Advanced material characterisation: Utilising sophisticated techniques to better understand the chemical and physical properties of SCMs, allowing for more precise blending and optimisation of their use in cement mixtures.
- Data-driven decision making: Implementing machine learning and big data analysis to predict the performance of different SCM combinations, allowing for real-time adjustments in cement production based on available SCM sources and desired concrete properties.
- Focus on local sourcing: Prioritising the use of locally available SCMs to reduce transportation costs and environmental impact.
- Development of new SCM processing techniques: Research into methods to enhance the reactivity and performance of less readily usable SCMs through processes like activation or modification.
- Life cycle analysis (LCA) integration: Using LCA to assess the full environmental impact of different SCMs and optimise their use to minimise carbon emissions throughout the cement production process.
- Regulatory frameworks and standards:Increased adoption of building codes and industry standards that promote the use of SCMs and set targets for reduced carbon emissions in cement production.
– Kanika Mathur
GMDC Inks Long-Term Limestone Supply Deal With JK Cement
GMDC, J K Cement Ltd. Tie-up for Limestone from Lakhpat Punrajpur Mine
JK Cement Acquires Majority Stake in Saifco Cement to Expand in J&K
‘Steel’ing the Show
WCA President Emphasises Major Changes in Global Cement Industry
GMDC Inks Long-Term Limestone Supply Deal With JK Cement
GMDC, J K Cement Ltd. Tie-up for Limestone from Lakhpat Punrajpur Mine
JK Cement Acquires Majority Stake in Saifco Cement to Expand in J&K
‘Steel’ing the Show
WCA President Emphasises Major Changes in Global Cement Industry
Trending News
-
Concrete3 weeks ago
FLSmidth & Co proposes changes in its board
-
Concrete3 weeks ago
Digital tools have improved quality control and consistency
-
Concrete4 weeks ago
India Cements Announces Management Reshuffle Post UltraTech Buyout
-
Concrete4 weeks ago
JK Lakshmi Cement Urges GST Cut, Plans Expansion in Bihar